Traditional Banana Pudding

Traditional Banana Pudding

$12.00
  • Made fresh daily — never from a mix
  • Real vanilla wafers & Chessman cookies
  • Free pickup in Bowie, MD
  • Secure checkout — Shop Pay, Visa, Mastercard, Amex

The classic that started it all — rich, creamy banana pudding done right.

One family recipe, made fresh every single day. Real bananas, real cream, no shortcuts. This is the one that made people start asking for more.

Sweet • Creamy • Addictive

Allergens: Contains milk and wheat (our vanilla wafers and Chessman cookies are wheat-based). Made without nuts. If you have a food allergy, please call us on (240) 413-1345 before ordering.

Before you order

How fresh is it?
Made fresh, in small batches, from one family recipe. No mix, no shortcuts. Keep it refrigerated and eat it within a few days — though in our experience that isn't usually a problem.
How do I get it?
Jars can ship, or you can collect them free from the shop at 15480 Annapolis Rd, Suite 204, Bowie MD. Half pans and full pans are pickup only — they're made to order and don't travel well.
What's the difference between a jar and a pan?
A jar is a single serving for one person. Half pans and full pans are catering sizes, made to order for cookouts, church, birthdays and anything where you're feeding a room. Give us a little notice on the big ones.
How much notice do you need for a pan?
Order as far ahead as you can, especially around holidays and weekends. If you need one quickly, call us on (240) 413-1345 and we'll tell you honestly whether we can do it.
Which flavor should I start with?
Traditional, if you've never had ours — it's the recipe everything else is built on. Cookie Butter is where people tend to get into trouble.